What justice is potentially coming for 79-year-old cyclist killed by hit-and-run driver in Chilliwack?
Driver was later arrested and released, still facing possible penalties ranging from a MVA fine to a lengthy prison sentence
November 18, 2026
Two months after 79-year-old Catherine “Kitty” Dunham was killed by a hit-and-run driver in a pick-up truck while she rode her bike near Portage Park, the driver hasn’t faced charges.
Dunham, who was known as Kitty and known around the community out to Rosedale for riding her bike every day, was at the intersection of Portage Avenue and Woodbine Street at approximately 6 p.m. on Sept. 19 when she was struck and killed by the driver of a red Chevy Silverado crew-cab pickup who fled the scene.
The incident happened when an Amazon delivery van stopped for Dunham at the intersection, according to a witness who said the driver of the pickup went around the delivery van striking Dunham on her bike. The witness reported to Global that the driver turned around further down Portage before fleeing the scene.
Four days after the hit-and-run death, Chilliwack RCMP issued a news release stating that the vehicle was located and seized. An adult male was arrested and released pending further investigation.
The Lower Mainland Integrated Collision Analysis and Reconstruction Service (ICARS) attended the scene. Mounties said investigators would continue to work closely with ICARS and the BC Coroners Service as they advance the investigation.
Alcohol and drugs were not believed to be factors in the collision.
Chilliwack RCMP was asked for an update this week as to whether the driver had yet faced charges under the Criminal Code or the Motor Vehicle Act.
“The matter is still under investigation, and no charges have been laid at this time,” RCMP spokesperson Cpl. Carmen Kiener told Something Worth Reading.
A large memorial with flowers, a sign and a photo of Kitty was built up at the intersection on the southwest corner of Woodbine and Portage. Two months later, a more modest memorial was still there.
What charges could be considered?
At the extreme ends of the spectrum, the driver alleged to have struck and killed Dunham could face as a little as a $368 fine for failing to remain at the scene of an accident under section 68(1) of the Motor Vehicle Act (MVA) up to a maximum of life in prison for dangerous operation causing death or failure to stop after an accident resulting in death, both under section 320 of the Criminal Code.
The fact that ICARS was involved and there were at least a couple of witnesses means the details of what actually happened should already be known by investigators.
That the driver has not yet been charged after two months is not unusual. Investigations of this seriousness can take time after which police may forward the file on to the Public Prosecution Service to consider charges.
The following are the provincial MVA offences potentially relevant to the driver of the pickup truck that day: failure to remain at scene; driving without due care and attention; driving without reasonable consideration; speed relative to conditions; failure to take precautions for vulnerable road users; speeding; unsafe passing; and/or failure to yield.
The following subsections of section 320 of the Criminal Code would be on the list of what prosecutors might consider: failure to stop after an accident, failure to stop after an accident involving bodily harm; failure to stop after an accident resulting in death; dangerous operation of a motor vehicle; dangerous operation causing bodily harm; dangerous operation causing death; or, and this is highly unlikely, criminal negligence causing death under section 220 of the Code.
The latter two offences and failure to stop resulting in death come with a maximum life sentence. The other serious offences come with maximums of 10 or 14 year in prosecuted by indictment. The first two failure-to-stop offences and dangerous-operation offences can be prosecuted summarily with lower maximum sentences.
It’s important to know that a fatal collision does not automatically constitute a criminal offenceeaving the scene can constitute an offence regardless of who caused the crash.
Tara Hartshorne knows this all too well as her 19-year-old daughter Chloe Des Rocher was killed by Daniel Beeke who was driving a pickup truck when he struck and killed her on August 2, 2022 at an intersection in Rosedale. The 24-year-old Beeke was not charged criminally, he never apologized, and he fought the MVA charge he faced and it was dropped.
As for the hit-and-run driver who killed Kitty Dunham, leaving the scene is what could be his biggest problem. Under section 320.16(3) of the Code, failure to stop after an accident resulting in death, the Crown must establish that the driver committed the underlying failure-to-stop offence and knew, or was reckless as to whether, the collision resulted in death or bodily harm from which death subsequently resulted.
A witness said the driver continued down the road then stopped and turned around before fleeing. If true, this could suggest recklessness. Prosecutors also don’t actually have to prove the driver knew the cyclist died. Awareness of a potentially serious injury, or recklessness about whether such an injury occurred, can satisfy the relevant mens rea.
Also crucial, Crown does not have to establish that the collision was caused by dangerous or negligent driving to prove the driver is guilty of failure to stop.
Dangerous driving causing death is a higher bar and unlikely to be charged. Criminal negligence causing death is higher again.
All of the above is speculation about possible outcomes but, as stated, the incident is still under investigation, according to the Chilliwack RCMP.
While this has likely already been done, investigators asked anyone with CCTV or dash-camera footage of a burgundy/red 2021 Chevrolet Silverado crew cab truck in the areas of Portage Avenue, Woodbine Street, Hazel Street, Menzies Street, and Yale Road around 6 p.m. on Sept. 19, 2026 to contact the Chilliwack RCMP at 604-792-4611 and quote file number 2026-42122.
-30-
Want to support independent journalism?
Consider becoming a paid subscriber or make a one-time donation so I can continue this work.
Paul J. Henderson
pauljhenderson@gmail.com
facebook.com/PaulJHendersonJournalist
instagram.com/wordsarehard_pjh
x.com/PeeJayAitch
wordsarehard-pjh.bsky.social
